Whole vs. Web Carbs for Diabetes

Most individuals with diabetes should depend on counting carbohydrates after they eat meals to assist handle their blood sugar ranges. 

However that may change into trickier when meals labels generally differentiate between “whole carbohydrates” and “web carbohydrates”. 

What’s the distinction between these two varieties of carbohydrates and which one do you have to use to your diabetes administration? 

This text will clarify what whole carbohydrates are, what web carbohydrates are, and decide when to make use of every quantity. 

Whole vs. Web Carbs for Diabetes

Why is carbohydrate counting necessary? 

On the molecular degree, carbohydrates are damaged down into glucose within the bloodstream that solely insulin can break down and assist the physique’s cells to digest. 

In case you reside with insulin-dependent diabetes, counting carbohydrates will subsequently assist inform your insulin dosage selections. 

In case you reside with non-insulin-dependent diabetes, chances are you’ll rely carbohydrates to raised calibrate oral diabetes remedy like Metformin, and even train, to assist handle blood sugar ranges. 

Since folks with diabetes both battle to make sufficient insulin naturally or their our bodies make no insulin in any respect, ensuring one is conscious of the variety of carbohydrates in a meals that’s consumed is significant to good well being and wellbeing. 

What are whole carbohydrates? 

Based on the Meals and Drug Administration (FDA), whole carbohydrates inform you absolutely the whole variety of carbohydrates a serving dimension of a given meals has. 

In case you reside with diabetes, this additionally nominally tells you the way your blood sugar will probably be affected by a sure meals. The “whole” implies that the quantity is comprised of 4 issues: 

  • Whole sugar – That is the whole grams of naturally occurring sugars which might be discovered within the serving dimension of a given meals
  • Added sugar – That is the whole grams of artificially added sugar that had been added in the course of the processing of a sure meals (like dextrose or sucrose). Additionally generally discovered right here can be grams of sugar from desk sugar, honey, or agave nectar
  • Dietary fiber – Whole grams of fiber which can’t be damaged down simply by the GI tract of a human being 
  • Sugar alcohols – Whole grams of sugar alcohols. These are a sort of sugar (polyol) with a barely totally different chemical make-up than added sugar, resembling each sugar and alcohol. They’ve minimal results on blood sugars and are generally added to meals to provide them a sweeter style, with out the added carbohydrates and energy. Examples of sugar alcohol embody: xylitol, sorbitol, maltitol, and erythritol 

Collectively, these 4 numbers comprise the whole variety of carbohydrates in a given serving dimension of a meals. 

Whereas that is an especially useful manner to determine how a meals will have an effect on your blood sugar, it doesn’t inform the entire story. 

What are web carbohydrates? 

Web carbohydrates symbolize the whole variety of carbohydrates that may really have an effect on blood sugar ranges. Typically they’re referred to as “digestible” and even “influence” carbs. 

Whereas there isn’t a official definition of the time period “web carbohydrate”, for people who find themselves both consuming a low carbohydrate weight loss program or for whom counting carbohydrates is extraordinarily necessary (i.e. folks with diabetes), it is very important know calculate this. 

Since naturally occurring fiber isn’t damaged down within the small gut, the carbohydrates that accompany this macronutrient don’t have an effect on blood sugar ranges. 

Moreover, subtracting sugar alcohols from a meals (sometimes they solely exist in processed meals) helps provide the web carbohydrates as effectively, since they’re additionally not digested in the identical manner a typical serving of sugar is. 

Research present that sugar alcohols don’t appear to have a serious influence on blood sugar ranges, however folks’s particular person responses can differ. For this reason sugar alcohols are generally added to “sugar-free” candies, ice cream, and bubble gum, though they will trigger bloating and GI discomfort. 

Sugar alcohols appear to solely be absorbed into the bloodstream briefly, after which exit the physique by way of urine, making their influence on blood sugars minimal. 

How do you calculate web carbohydrates? 

To calculate web carbohydrates, one would take the whole variety of carbohydrates and subtract each the whole variety of grams of fiber and the variety of grams of sugar alcohol.

Nevertheless, since sugar alcohols can have an effect on blood sugar minimally, and everybody digests sugar alcohol in a different way, some folks might desire to subtract solely half the variety of sugar alcohols for web carbohydrates. 

Web Carb = Whole Carbs – Fiber – Sugar Alcohols (or 50% of sugar alcohols) 

The ensuing quantity is the web variety of carbohydrates in a serving of meals, and for optimum blood sugar administration, one would rely that because the quantity to base insulin and/or oral diabetes remedy on. 

Mindy Nichols, RD, CDE says, “Web carbs are solely estimations, as everybody’s digestive techniques and bodily processes are totally different. Working together with your physician, experiment and see what works greatest for you!” 

It’s necessary to notice that should you reside in some nations exterior of the US, the “whole carbohydrate” quantity already has the whole grams of fiber subtracted out, so there isn’t a have to do the equation. 

Execs and cons of counting web carbohydrates 

Counting web carbohydrates is a wonderful method to fine-tune your diabetes administration, however it won’t be for everybody. Listed below are some execs and cons of approaching this fashion of consuming:


  • Consuming this fashion promotes entire, unprocessed meals 
  • It incentivizes consuming extra fiber
  • Decreases threat for hypoglycemia 
  • It’s a much less restrictive manner of consuming (can promote consuming extra fruit and different increased carbohydrate entire meals attributable to their excessive fiber content material) 


  • Will not be appropriate for everybody’s consuming plan or diabetes remedy routine 
  • Can lead to consuming a lot of “sugar-free” candies and treats that aren’t as wholesome (if the main target is simply growing the variety of sugar alcohols and never fiber) 
  • Isn’t all the time 100% correct for dosing 
  • Meals labels aren’t all the time out there (for example at household or buddy’s houses, and when out at a restaurant) 

Lauren Plunkett, RDN, CDCES, writer of Type One Willpower, encourages folks with diabetes to extend their consumption of fiber-rich meals to boost insulin sensitivity, decrease irritation, and promote the microbiome for a wholesome physique and thoughts. 

“Everybody digests and absorbs meals in a different way. This could rely upon age, the atmosphere contained in the intestine, and exercise degree. No two stomachs are alike! Since we’re distinctive digesters, it’s necessary to find out which meals sources of fiber are most suitable with our system and blood sugar targets, whether or not or not we select to subtract fiber grams from whole carbohydrates.” 


Understanding each the whole variety of carbohydrates and the web variety of carbohydrates in a meals you’re consuming is necessary, particularly should you reside with diabetes. 

Calculating the web carbohydrates of a meals can fine-tune each your remedy dosages in addition to your diabetes administration, leading to higher blood sugar ranges, decrease hba1c ranges, and an enchancment in high quality of life. 

Nevertheless, consuming for diabetes will not be a one-size-fits-all endeavor, and everybody’s experiences might differ. 

At all times discuss together with your physician earlier than making any adjustments to your consuming and/or remedy administration plan.

Latest Recipes

More Recipes Like This